Threads

Not Circling: dropping the container while keeping the practice

7 tweets · February 2023 · 106 likes · 2 retweets · read on Twitter

recently experimented with some friends in doing Not Circling (full name "I Can't Believe It's Not Circling") it's basically like Circling except if there's a conflict between your concept of Circling and what you want or what feels best, you do the latter fucking loved it

maybe Not Circling is an advanced technique, or maybe arguably this is always sort of what Circling is supposed to be, or what Circling is once you take the training wheels off?

idk! I've only done a dozen circles, but I've lived a decade in cultures aiming to live in a way that makes sense all the time and isn't just in a container and this felt like a really potent bridge between the two

Malcolm Ocean 🏴‍☠️ @Malcolm_Ocean ·

we agree to behave in thus and such a way, for the duration of the container (circling, whatever) what is our agreement for how we behave when the bell goes off and the container ends?

some specific examples of things that happened that mightn't've in a Circle: - I moved across the room to be way closer to someone who said he felt disconnected from me - some people played cards in the corner for a bit - someone wrote a theory on a whiteboard all very alive!

video expounding extensively on this topic & adjacent ones

Malcolm Ocean 🏴‍☠️ @Malcolm_Ocean ·

had a great convo w @FluidityAudio today about I Can't Believe It's Not Circling and the nature of containers and social norms and pretending and you can watch it here! youtu.be/aILIG13lEYk

people being like "but Circling where you do what you want is just Circling" smh

Malcolm Ocean 🏴‍☠️ @Malcolm_Ocean ·

@simon_ohler @the_wilderless @positive_loop people keep saying this ^ but I fucking hate it. Circling is a scaffold that gives people a taste for a kind of magical group experience Circling is ALSO an experience you can have where you collectively find that magic with zero scaffold ...but it's the first thing first.

even if you're a pro who feels very liberated to do what you want during a circle, if you conceive of yourself as "doing Circling" then that is totally gonna give you a bunch of assumptions about the situation that will constrain your noticings & behavior

Malcolm Ocean 🏴‍☠️ @Malcolm_Ocean ·

@simon_ohler @the_wilderless @positive_loop and I get annoyed when people respond to "let's do Circling except unhinged" with "well that's just Circling". if you call it "Circling", people will tend to correct their own and each others' behavior towards some concept of what Circling is, and this is good—for learning!